Your Cat Isn’t Plotting Against You (and Other Myths We Need to Debunk)
- Share via
Spend any time around people who own cats and you’ll hear the same little “truths” float through conversations like background noise. The kinds of phrases that get passed along so casually no one ever stops to question where they came from. Over time, these myths settle into how we treat and interpret the cats in our lives, even though many of them are wrong. Some are holdovers from folklore, others from outdated behavioral advice, but all of them have real consequences for how cats are understood.
NEWSLETTER
Looking to adopt or raise a pet? Get expert tips and tricks right in your mailbox.
Myth 1: Cats Are Antisocial and Aloof
The “cats don’t care about people” idea sits at the center of nearly every other misunderstanding. It’s the one you hear at parties, in vet offices, in memes, from people who dislike cats and from people who love them. It’s the idea that cats are standoffish little housemates who only acknowledge us when the food bowl is empty.
In reality, cats form intense emotional bonds with their people. They rely on routine, social cues and emotional stability more than most owners realize. There’s a 2019 study out of Oregon State University where cats scored almost identically to human toddlers on attachment tests. Yes, toddlers.
When their person is gone, many cats display behaviors that get misread as “quirks” or ignored completely: hiding, pacing, vocalizing, destructive scratching, lashing out at other household members, or urinating on personal belongings. These aren’t acts of detachment. They’re stress responses.
If you see your cat as an indifferent roommate, you’ll miss what they’re actually telling you. They notice when you leave. They care that you’re gone. They just express it differently.
Myth 2: Cats Misbehave Out of Spite
You hear this one a lot. “I know she’s mad at me, she peed on my bed the night I got home,” reports a coworker over coffee. Or a friend who is a new mom claims, “He’s jealous of the baby, that’s why he started swatting.” I’ve heard variations of these lines hundreds of times, often delivered with exasperation. And I understand why. From a human lens, it looks exactly like revenge. But spite isn’t how cats operate.
When a cat pees on your bed while you’re away, they aren’t plotting. They’re overwhelmed. Your bed smells like you more than anywhere else in the house, so mingling their scent with yours is a way to self-soothe in your absence.
When the household dynamic changes — a new pet, partner or baby — cats often retreat, lash out, or change their habits because their sense of safety has shifted. They’re reacting to the environment, not taking emotional revenge.
Calling it “spite” turns a communication problem into a moral judgment, which usually leads to frustration instead of solutions.
Myth 3: Cats Are Independent and Low Maintenance
This is one of the most damaging misconceptions. People decide to get a cat because “they’re easier than dogs.” No walks, no obedience classes, no fuss. Just food, litter and vibes. But cats are not houseplants.
They are domesticated animals that depend on us for everything. Indoor cats especially need daily interaction and mental engagement because we’ve removed their natural hunting outlet. If you don’t give them structured ways to burn off energy, they’ll make their own fun, which often turns into behavior people label as “bad.” Scratching furniture, knocking things over, climbing where they shouldn’t, vocalizing constantly — all of these are ways to fill unmet needs.
They also need regular veterinary care, grooming, nail trims and enrichment. Some cats are naturally lower energy, sure, but plenty need consistent attention to thrive. Thinking of them as “low maintenance” sets up both cat and owner for trouble.
Myth 4: Cats Are Agressive By Nature
“My cat is just mean” is something I hear constantly. True aggression just for aggression’s sake in cats is actually rare. What most people interpret as aggression is usually normal communication that gets ignored or misread.
Play is a major culprit. Young cats, especially males, often play rough. To you, being ambushed while walking down the hallway feels like an attack. To them, it’s playtime. Overstimulation is another big one. A cat may be sitting peacefully, half asleep, when a hand suddenly starts stroking them over and over. Their nervous system hits its limit, the subtle signs go unseen, and they swat or bite. That’s not malice. That’s “please stop” after several missed warnings.
Pain and hunger also lead to what looks like aggression. Cats with arthritis, dental disease or injuries often lash out when touched in sore spots. Hungry cats sometimes nip to get your attention. And fear aggression, though dramatic, is pure panic, not cruelty. Understanding the context behind these behaviors changes everything.
Myth 5: Cats Can’t Be Trained
This one always gets a laugh. People accept that you can train dogs, birds, pigs, even rats, but mention training a cat and they look at you like you suggested teaching a tree to sit. Meanwhile, their cat comes running at the sound of a can opening and hides when the carrier comes out. That’s training.
Cats are excellent at learning patterns. With positive reinforcement, they can learn to come when called, sit calmly while you prepare food, use scratching posts consistently, accept grooming and more. Clicker training works wonderfully. The key is understanding what motivates them and being consistent.
Training isn’t about making cats perform tricks. It’s about creating structure and communication. Believing they can’t be trained just guarantees you’ll live with habits you don’t like.
Be a Care-Taker, Not a Myth-Maker
These myths stick around because they’re easy to repeat and hard to shake. But the truth is far more interesting. Cats aren’t aloof, spiteful, low maintenance, aggressive or untrainable. They’re sensitive, observant and emotional animals whose behavior makes perfect sense once you understand the “why” behind it. Letting go of old stories opens up space for real relationships with the cats we share our homes with.
MORE PETS
