Activation of granzyme B, a key cytolytic effector molecule of natural killer (NK) cells, requires removal of an N-terminal pro-domain. In mice, cathepsin C is required for granzyme processing and normal NK cell cytolytic function, whereas in patients with Papillon-Lefèvre syndrome (PLS), loss-of-function mutations in cathepsin C do not affect lymphokine activated killer (LAK) cell function. Here we demonstrate that resting PLS NK cells do have a cytolytic defect and fail to induce the caspase cascade in target cells. NK cells from these patients contain inactive granzyme B, indicating that cathepsin C is required for granzyme B activation in unstimulated human NK cells. However, in vitro activation of PLS NK cells with interleukin-2 restores cytolytic function and granzyme B activity by a cathepsin C-independent mechanism. This is the first documented example of a human mutation affecting granzyme B activity and highlights the importance of cathepsin C in human NK cell function.